Thank you to Svetlana for her review of THE SOLDIER’S RETURN, Heaven’s Pond Trilogy Book 2. Read the review in its entirety here and visit Svetlana’s Reads and Views:
“Characters: Main characters include Katarina, Ralf, Pieter van Diermen. With some characters I couldn’t tell if they were main or secondary, but I think those three are main characters. Katarina is a maid as well as a lover to Sebald Tucher. She seems to be in charge of everything and is more of a mistress. She also wants to take all the burdens on herself at the cost of friendships and relationships. Katarina is intelligent, resourceful but she tends to keep her heart guarded up, especially towards her surrogate daughter Isabeau. Ralf is the villain of the book who seems to be delusional and who sees evil everywhere. He is also a Catholic priest who feels faith is more important than anything else. (He also literally sees women who use herbs as witches because they don’t trust in god!) Pieter van Diermen is a difficult character for me to describe aside from the fact he has little to no taste in warfare and just wants to leave the soldier’s life. Despite his personal feelings, he has already been damaged by the war and the things he had to see and participate in.
“Theme: There is no glamour and glory in war.
“Plot: The story is in third person narrative from multiple points of view; namely from Pieter van Diemen’s, Katarina’s, Isabeau’s and Ralf’s points of view. There is definitely a psychological aspect to the novel because its not desensitized and constant ugly things happen to characters. The author, I feel, seems to ask how much can the characters handle before they reach a breaking point? I know that reading and witnessing horror in the story that’s rarely unremitting but continuous can drive any reader to exhaustion and weariness.
“Opinion: First of all, reading the first book in the series is a must because the reader will get lost with what’s going on as well as the characters and how they all know one another. Second of all, the book doesn’t glamorize fighting or wars at all, but instead its richly detailed about the travails that war has on men, women and children in 17th century. There is some plot in the story, but most of it is day to day situation that survivors have to go through such as securing food, hiding from rowdy soldiers, and trying to move on from horrors seen and inflicted, which I actually enjoyed a lot. If you are looking for realistic fiction, I would highly recommend the book.”
“Rating: 4 out of 5 (0: Stay away unless a masochist 1: Good for insomnia 2: Horrible but readable; 3: Readable and quickly forgettable, 4: Good, enjoyable 5: Buy it, keep it and never let it go.)”
Please visit Svetlana’s Reads and Views for more historical fiction reviews!